In Tennessee, where Carrie Underwood has long been embraced as country music royalty, her relationship with American Idol is entering a far more complicated chapter. The former Idol winner turned judge is reportedly at the center of behind-the-scenes strain, with producers making sweeping changes to the show in an effort to keep her comfortable and, frankly, to keep her from walking away altogether.
According to The Sun, Carrie struggled significantly during her first season behind the judges’ table. While the role should have felt like a full-circle moment for the singer, insiders claim the experience was far more overwhelming than expected. The backlash was intense, the scrutiny constant, and the noise from viewers louder than she was prepared for. That pressure reportedly followed her everywhere, even back home to Tennessee, where she usually finds stability and peace.
A production insider told The Sun that Carrie was deeply affected by criticism of her appearance and by negative fan reactions tied to her political associations. The backlash intensified after she performed at Donald Trump’s 2025 inauguration, which aired just days before the new season premiered.
Carrie Underwood Allegedly Causing American Idol Issues With MAGA Ties and Tennessee Homestands
“She had a hard time dealing with all the backlash and viewer reaction from last season after all the Trump stuff,” the source said. “The noise from the fans was so much louder than she was prepared for and that got to her.”
Behind the scenes, producers scrambled. Hollywood Week was reportedly scrapped altogether, significantly reducing the amount of time judges had to film in Los Angeles. Instead, production leaned heavily into filming in Nashville, a city with deep music roots and a place Carrie considers home. Filming was also expanded in Hawaii, with weeks-long shoots at Disney’s Aulani Resort in Oahu, far longer than in previous seasons. Most notably, Carrie was allowed to bring her entire family along for the journey.
“A big part of why they changed up the format was to accommodate the judges’ wants more, specifically Carrie,” the insider revealed. There were even discussions, the source claimed, that Carrie might not return at all if those accommodations weren’t met. Ultimately, the show agreed to her terms. As one source bluntly put it: “They couldn’t afford to lose her.”
Meanwhile, Rob Shuter’s Naughty But Nice reports that the controversy hasn’t gone unnoticed by executives. While Carrie insists she avoids politics, previously saying “nobody wins” when celebrities weigh in, insiders say producers are increasingly nervous about her becoming a political lightning rod.
“Idol is supposed to be feel-good, family-friendly television,” one source explained. “The last thing producers want is a judge turning into a political lightning rod.”
Fans Weigh In
The concern isn’t Carrie’s talent. It’s distraction. Once viewers stop focusing on contestants and start arguing about judges, the brand takes a hit and American Idol thrives on mass appeal.
“People still watch this show? It’s been lame for a long time now,” one person commented. “I’m not watching it because of her political affiliation so I guess this describes me!” said another. “Half the country is a lot of viewers. Couldn’t have hurt American Idol much. Smart move,” a third comment read.
For now, Carrie appears calm, professional, and recommitted. But the fact that an entire season was restructured around her comfort speaks volumes. Back in Tennessee, where she once dreamed of this stage, Carrie Underwood is still a star, just one navigating a very different spotlight than the one she stepped into nearly two decades ago.
Kenna Raye 
Kendra Quinn 
Emma Taylor 
